Thursday, November 26, 2009

silence

The last three months have been really strange for me. I've alluded to it in some of my previous posts and this morning I really felt the need to write about it. Let's call it another attempt at catharsis. I feel like I got a bit "lost" over the last few months. It started with some testing issues that I can't go into, but the breaking point came when Barry died. Somehow, and I had no idea it was happening at the time, the way I saw the world began to shift. Not in a "life is so unfair and I want to die" kind of way. Just a real sadness and a sense that my picture of the way we are expected to live our lives is different to the reality.

Barry was a minister, and an amazing man. I never kept in touch with him as often as I should have over the last few years, and that's something I regret, but the significant role he played in my life cannot be disputed. But I loved it when we spoke. And suddenly, he was silent.

Man, did I pray that he wouldn't be.

My first experience of religion was when I was a child. My mom was catholic and my dad is Methodist and as kids my brother and I were asked to choose which church we wanted to belong to. This meant very little to us; we had hardly spent any time in either so our frame of reference was limited. My brother took the lead and suggested we go to the Methodist church; I think he had friends that went there so knew it was cool. I remember this causing a bit of friction in our family, although I wasn't sure why. I took it to be my mom feeling rejected by her sons. So my first experience was a tad bitter.

We went to a large Methodist church that I eventually became a part of actively - to the point that I worked for the Church on a full-time basis. I loved it. And loved that my life was significant. People matter (as my friend and author Trevor Hudson says) and I could live that daily.

It was during this time that I met Barry and was the time of my life that I was most at battle with myself internally. I remember someone walking up to me during that time and offering to pray for me. I was quite taken aback by it - most people who knew me saw this gregarious (and slightly overweight) youth pastor who was always making jokes or singing. We sat down and he said "people see boldness when inside you cry". The tears streamed and I walked out thinking that I was free from this internal battle.

But the battle raged and was exhausting. I believed in a God who said he died for me. I loved a scripture that said he had my name written into the palm of his hands - the same palms that had nails driven through them (yes, I know it should be wrists but work with me you detail-types). This God promised to ease my burden and love me. Nothing could seperate me from his love, Paul wrote.

At the same time I was fighting (to the point of exhaustion) my attraction to men. I was petrified that someone would find out because it would mean that the one thing that God apparently hated within me would have me excluded. I was very aware that something could seperate me from his love, or at least that's what I was being told. I was fighting something I really felt no control over and had no choice in because admitting it meant exclusion and, at a base-level, unemployment.

I prayed. I fasted. I walked in victory, even though I wasn't victorious. I spoke my heterosexuality into being. I secretly joined ministries that said they offered Godly solutions. I stood on God's word (at times literally) screaming for some sense of relief, and I cried. I wanted to please God above all-else.

This wasn't a temporary quick thing. I went through this for years. I moved to Cape Town and continued my journey to being the man God wanted me to be. I prayed and prayed.

All I ever got in return was silence.

I experienced God through people. But those same people eventually excluded me from the Church and the community that I loved when I exposed my battle with my homosexualty and the fact that I wasn't seeing God's victorious hand in it. I assumed that the good came from God and the bad from humanity, but I question that now.

And when I joined the throngs begging God to let a man lost at sea be found and returned to his wife, the church he led and the two young kids who would never know him if he didn't walk in the door again, I received my usual response.

Silence.

I have been criticised when writing this blog about my attempts to be gay and a christian. I've always tried to respond from a place of strength and to allow people their opinions. Around the time of Barry's death a person left a comment on a past blog that negated my journey, and reminded me that I had no place in the kingdom of God because I love a man. I went home and prayed about it. And I received my usual response.

Silence.

I'm disillusioned by silence.

And I'm not sure that you who I thought was out there, really is.

And it breaks my heart.

And it frees me.

...

...

...

Silence.

22 comments:

Gill said...

Oh Clive, my heart aches for you. While you have been wrestling with this for the last few months I have been having my own crisis of faith, so I truly know what you are going through. Wish I could say something profound here but I can't because all I feel right now is confusion!

John van de Laar said...

Hi Clive,

Thanks for sharing your story so openly and vulnerably. Your commitment to living awake is more significant for those who read your words than you will know.

I don't want to minimise your words or your struggle with platitudes or glib responses, so I hope what I'm about to say won't be viewed as such. I went through a crisis of faith and identity not unlike yours a few years ago - ironically while I was also working full time at the church you mention. So, I write from a deep resonance with your journey.

First, I want to suggest that silence is exactly where God (or whatever you want to call him/her) is found. Any other God is simply unworthy of the name. But, for most of us, to find this God requires a death of the smaller, "out there", "superman swooping in to save the day" kind of God that is too often taught in church.

Second, as a response to this, I believe that what you're experiencing - as painful as it is - is actually a time of tremendous possibility and opportunity. Perhaps you can move beyond the binary "Is there a God or not" thinking that puts Believers and Atheists at odds with one another, and discover a third way, where we refuse to believe in a God that is wrapped up in political or religious agendas, and discover another way to view and experience God - as an infinite, mysterious, all-encompassing, conscious life that fills everything and everyone.

I guess what I'm trying to say in a round-about way is that the God you're struggling with now is not the only God around - and perhaps s/he needs to die for you before you can find a more authentic divinity.

Or maybe not. Whatever your final resting place in terms of faith, if it's authentic for you and leads you into a life of wholeness and wholeness-giving, that's a tremendous gift.

Perhaps Barry is silent, and perhaps God is silent, but there are those of us who have walked closely with both of them who are willing to share our voices with you if you need us. And if you still need a minister to celebrate your wedding next year, you know who to call.

For what it's worth...

Simply-Mel said...

What a heart-wrenching post. Difficult to say something that doesnt sound trite.

I have never walked in your shoes. I have had my own crisis of faith and have come to a new place of understanding, acceptance and freedom within my relationship with Christ.

I absolutely HATE that this is your journey, that you could possibly even imagine that He doenst care or that He isnt who you thought He was. It tears me up inside. But no-one can walk your road.

I think Barry would be devastated that his death has brought you such confusion and heartache when he is home.

I hope you see my heart here sir. I wish we could hang out a bit. Not to tell you everything you already know but to just be.

Cyber relationships are all well and fine but nothing compares to sharing IRL.

Thanks for being bold enough to go here Clive.

xx

Barbara said...

Clive, I think there are many people out here who have the same feelings. At some time you may reconcile yourself to it all, because at the moment you are still battling with your grief and all the injustice. M silence came at the death of my uncle aged 40 who left 3 children. The worst part was that he died at home and my cousins saw their mother trying to resucitate him. 'why did mummy hit daddy' How do you explain to a 6 year old that mummy was not the cause of daddy's death. I sat in his funeral as hundreds of Catholics pushed past his coffin for their Holy Communion. I have never got over that feeling of absolute digust. I hope that one day you will find your faith. Mine is long gone because if there is a God then his cruelty is beyond contempt. Love you Clive, big cuddles xxxx

Celeste said...

You know what concerns me? You've written that like that's the end of the story, and I can imagine that that would be very painful for you. But, I feel like it should be a start. So you said it frees you, and I get the impression that you mean it's freeing you from something that was wrong, that you were stupid and naive to believe in. For me the freeing part should be about a new start - a new kind of relationship with this higher power that is within us all and around us. But maybe you haven't come to that point yet?

Justin said...

Clive, I really hope everything falls in place for you. And I admire your guts.

Sandi said...

Wow Clive. This is SO honest. I dont know much, but what I do know is that God can handle your questions... He's ok with it. He's even ok with you not liking Him or believing He exists. This is your (the two of you) journey, walk in it...

allie said...

Have emailed you, my friend

Anonymous said...

Wow - this is all very interesting.

I must say that in the year or so that I have 'known' you - I have always thought your faith was unwavering. Questioning your faith doesnt mean not believing. If anything it means your willingness to try and understand it.

You will always get silence. But thats why its called faith. I dont care what it is you believe in, but you just have to believe in something. You have to have faith in your faith. Its not going to magically present itself as some tangible, visual, audible and tactile manifestation. Its just something thats in you. I cant detail what I believe in here - but you can trust that I believe in something. And I often have days where i feel unworthy - but I think that just affirms my faith - that I believe in something.

Again I am really sorry about your friend, and I can understand your reflex and your questioning as well as your need to hear something other than silence. But horrible, really incredibly horrible things, happen every day to people who dont deserve it. Its just this unfortunate reality we find ourselves in. I often philosophise and contemplate the human condition in my mind (usually at night where I face all my deepest fears in my bed and fall asleep from exhaustion) and its too much for my little brain to think about.

Just remember the title of your blog. Its in the now. Where you should be focusing. Right now.

Again i cant comment on Christianity as a faith - but I do relate to the whole homosexual issue. (And you have also rationalized that at length)...

You just have to find whatever works. Whatever semblance of happiness you can hold on to. You could have remained with the church, been a non-practising homosexual (I say this because you can never be reformed to a hetrosexual - you can just choose not to sleep with men but you will always remain gay), and made the people who believe being gay is the ultimate sin happy. Or you can do what youre doing right now and make you and your partner happy. Im glad you are choosing the latter.

Just keep the faith. Live in the now and keep the faith. Its there. Its silent. But its there. Make plans, set goals, work to achieve them, but every now and then, stop and drink it all in.

cm.

Brenda said...

Clive, my silence does not suggest I am not touched. My silence is a reflection of the deepness of what you have shared. Words would mess it up. This I know, you are not alone in the silence.

daysofourroy production team said...

I really liked the post. I too struggled with the silence. But my (earthly) father is often extremely silent, when I wish he would say something. That he is silent, does not mean he does not love me unconditionally.

It just means he doesn't express himself in words.

absolutwillie said...

*hug*

(word verification: grace ntl)

Wenchy said...

I wish I knew a simplistic answer to such a heartfelt, sincere and vulnerable post, or maybe had something worthwhile to contribute.

I don't.

...but I so appreciate your humanity.

Anonymous said...

Hey Clive... What an honest and heart-wrenching post. What to say? I guess i wonder if its more that you are afraid that God doesn't believe in you than you are losing your belief in him. Kind of trying to protect yourself from what you imagine he may think of you (He knew you were gay when he chose you! It wasn't like he got a surprise!).

The truth is that he has more faith in you than possibly you have in him right now - i believe that. Completely.

I'm hanging in there with you Clive. [hug] Ciao. Lisa.

jacki janse van rensburg said...

your post breaks my heart. and makes me love you even more.

and, as i have said to you before, in jest that time, it doesn't have to be a 'crisis of faith'. it is a journey. a journey that continues through life, an exploration. you have, and you will, figure out your own path. and that's ok..

i am awed by the sensitive and loving comments. you are very loved indeed. especially john van de laar sounds like an awesome person!

Citizen X said...

My feeling is that we leave the cave alone (see Plato), but when we finally get outside we join a community of people staring at the sun. I hope I find my way out and I hope I see you there.

Deborah said...

A big hug to you Clive! I think most of us can taste what a mystery life is ... and also how precious. Just rest in His perfect arms ... you are loved unconditionally. Love Debs

Joanne said...

I was here.

I wish you could spend some time with Mel and Allie.

Delme Linscott said...

Hey Clive,
Your honesty is therapeutic my friend! Your "silence" is felt by many of us. Remember that for Elijah, the voice of God was not in the noise, but in the still small voice.
Strength and peace,
Delme

jacki janse van rensburg said...

i don't think He is silent. i think He is speaking to you. loud. clear. and with so much love!

i hear His voice in the responses to your post..

Anonymous said...

ur life is full of moments. take nothing away from them.they deserve to be ripe and full no matter if positive or negative.when we question the moments they loose some of that ripeness. they become clouded with human positives and negatives...their energy shifts and we can loose the actual meaning. we can question, but know that they are happening for a reason and u will only get bigger from your moments... believe in yourself, believe in the power of ur moments and u will know the silence is not silent at all...even the silence pushes u forward, pushes u to write this, pushes u to ripeness and fullness.pushes u to believe that perhaps YOU and everything u are...are god...

ArleneD said...

Love you Clive. I was so totally moved my John van de Laar's comment. Wow!!! Thank you for your courage and for sharing it with us.